Question 1

What is A Well-Regulated Militia by Saul Cornell about?

Accepted Answer

A Well-Regulated Militia by Saul Cornell presents a comprehensive history of Second Amendment interpretation, arguing that both modern views are historically incorrect. Cornell demonstrates that the Founding Fathers understood the right to bear arms as a "civic right"—an obligation citizens owed to participate in well-regulated militias, rather than an individual or collective right.

Question 2

Who should read A Well-Regulated Militia by Saul Cornell?

Accepted Answer

A Well-Regulated Militia is ideal for constitutional scholars, historians, law students, and anyone seeking to understand the Second Amendment debate beyond partisan talking points. The book appeals to readers interested in American constitutional history and those wanting historical context for contemporary gun policy discussions rather than ideological arguments.

Question 3

Is A Well-Regulated Militia worth reading?

Accepted Answer

A Well-Regulated Militia is worth reading for its thorough historical analysis and fresh perspective on a contentious constitutional issue. While some reviewers note Cornell's funding from gun control advocates, most praise the book's scholarly approach and ability to challenge assumptions held by both sides of the gun rights debate.

Question 4

What does Saul Cornell argue about the Second Amendment in A Well-Regulated Militia?

Accepted Answer

Saul Cornell argues that the Second Amendment established a "civic right" where citizens had an obligation to arm themselves for militia service, not personal protection. He demonstrates that both the modern "individual rights" and "collective rights" interpretations emerged in the 19th century, not during the founding era, making current debates historically unfounded.

Question 5

What are the main criticisms of A Well-Regulated Militia?

Accepted Answer

Critics argue that Cornell's research funding from the Joyce Foundation, which advocates gun control, creates bias toward supporting government regulation. Some reviewers also note that Cornell overlooks substantial historical evidence of the right to bear arms supporting individual self-defense and deterring tyrannical government.

Question 6

How does A Well-Regulated Militia explain the history of gun control in America?

Accepted Answer

A Well-Regulated Militia traces gun control's origins to the 19th century during America's first gun violence crisis, not the founding era. Cornell shows how the modern debate emerged during Reconstruction when Republicans and Democrats clashed over the Second Amendment's connection to the Fourteenth Amendment, with Democrats' victory establishing the "collective rights" interpretation for the next century.

Question 7

What is the "civic right" interpretation in A Well-Regulated Militia?

Accepted Answer

The "civic right" interpretation in A Well-Regulated Militia means citizens had both the right and obligation to bear arms specifically for militia service to protect their communities. Unlike individual self-defense or collective state militia rights, this civic duty required personal gun ownership to fulfill constitutional obligations for community defense against external and internal threats.

Question 8

What does Saul Cornell say about the Founding Fathers' views on gun rights?

Accepted Answer

According to Saul Cornell, the Founding Fathers viewed gun ownership as necessary for militia participation rather than personal protection, since individual self-defense rights were already protected under common law. Cornell argues there was no need for constitutional protection of hunting or self-defense rights, just as there was no need to guarantee rights to "eat, defecate, or procreate".

More like this

Key takeaways

The Right to Bear Arms: A Civic Duty Transformed

Militias and the Revolutionary Vision

From Constitutional Crisis to Amendment

Madison's Balancing Act and Public Safety

The Transformation to Individual Rights

Supreme Court Interpretations

Reclaiming Our Constitutional Heritage

A Well-Regulated Militia by Saul Cornell Summary

Overview of A Well-Regulated Militia

Similar books to A Well-Regulated Militia

More like this

Key takeaways

The Right to Bear Arms: A Civic Duty Transformed

Militias and the Revolutionary Vision

From Constitutional Crisis to Amendment

Madison's Balancing Act and Public Safety

The Transformation to Individual Rights

Supreme Court Interpretations

Reclaiming Our Constitutional Heritage

Quick Summary Mode - Read or listen to A Well-Regulated Militia Summary in 9 Minutes

Flash Card Mode - Top 10 Insights from A Well-Regulated Militia in a Nutshell

Fun Mode - A Well-Regulated Militia Lessons Told Through 24-Min Stories

Personalize Mode - Read or listen to A Well-Regulated Militia Summary in 0 Minutes

Download A Well-Regulated Militia PDF

Download A Well-Regulated Militia EPUB